(11-30-2021 04:39 PM)johnbragg Wrote: [ -> ] (11-30-2021 04:28 PM)Kit-Cat Wrote: [ -> ]Quote:The next meeting of the College Football Playoff management committee—which is comprised of the commissioners from all 10 Football Bowl Subdivision conferences and Notre Dame athletic director Jack Swarbrick—is scheduled for Dec. 1.
The outcome of that meeting will show whether the long process is nearing the final stages or still has a long way to go.
"Do I think it could go forward? Certainly," SEC commissioner Sankey said after the November meeting. "Do I think people could stop it? Absolutely, because we need unanimous consent to make this happen among the 11 participants."
https://currently.att.yahoo.com/att/coll...06808.html
We should be getting news then about the playoff by the end of the week.
I have said on numerous occasions there isn't much guidance on how this will impact bowls, particularly bowls that won't be directly involved in the 12 team playoff rounds.
This is the only real question. What happens to the Peach and the Cotton/Fiesta Bowl? Do the quarterfinals rotate (2 years in the system, 1 year out) like the semifinals did?
Quote:Will they continue to have access bowls?
If you count the top G5 champion getting a playoff bid, then yes. That's the access. That's it.
Quote:Access bowls for the 7th and 8th place conference champion I can see make sense. Perhaps 4 access bowls for teams ranked 13th through 18th as well as the 7th and 8th conference champions.
Um, no? The 7th and 8th best conference champions never got anything special, why should they start now? The MWC champ can play whatever 6-6 PAC team gets sent, the MAC and SBC champs can play each other, the CUSA and AAC champs can go to whatever bowl their conference scrapes up.
Quote:There wouldn't be much left of the bowl system if you had the top 8-10 games in the CFP.
Right, which is why they're not cooking up any extra Access Bowls for 7th & 8th conference champs or #13-18 in the rankings. They can go to the Citrus Bowl or the Music City Bowl or the Holiday Bowl or wherever, just like for the past 30 or so years since all the bowls went to conference tie-ins.
Quote:With it all smaller resources games I don't know how that will affect the demand for tie-ins. It could go B1G/SEC then everyone cleaning up behind them.
It pretty much already was? Less so this bowl cycle, because (as far as I can tell) the SEC decided to go with more of a mix. (Last cycle there were SEC vs Big games in Citrus, Tampa, Gator, Charlotte I think, Music City.)
The current post season setup is 4 access bowls, 2 in the semifinals and a NC game.
The BCS had 4 access bowls and 1 bowl double hosting a NC game.
The prestige and value go up being an access bowl vs. non-CFP game. This is why it makes sense to have 4 bowls in the quarters in the 12 team playoff and then 4 access bowls as traditionally been the case.
With the early iterations of the BCS where the TV money was not as big and you had 4 games (Rose, Fiesta, Sugar, Orange) there was space for other upper tier NYD games to exist. This space became more squeezed as the Cotton Bowl and Peach Bowl joined those ranks.
Last time around the Holiday Bowl, Texas Bowl and Citrus Bowl all through their hats into the ring as part of CFP bowl expansion. There was a vetting process and a selection of the Cotton and Peach to join the CFP. I'm sure bowls will try and angle to join the newly expanded CFP contract again as part of the CFP.
Whatever bowl doesn't get in the expanded contract will be infinitely marginalized to the point where they might as well be owned by ESPN. That is why I think we'll have access bowls as part of this and they are a good lead up to the bowls hosting the quarterfinals.
Oldest bowl games in America (not in CFP)
Sun Bowl 1935 (smallish stadium and TV market)
Gator Bowl 1945 (growing TV market)
Citrus Bowl 1946 (large TV market)
Liberty Bowl 1959 (smallish TV market)
Independence Bowl 1976 (tiny TV market)
Holiday Bowl 1978 (small stadium)
Outback Bowl 1986 (large TV market)
Guaranteed Rate Bowl 1989 (second tier Phoenix game)
Cheez-It Bowl 1990 (second tier Orlando game)
Las Vegas Bowl 1992 (growing TV market, new stadium)
Alamo Bowl 1993 (large TV market)
This is it as far as the pre-BCS games go. Only 5 are even capable of hosting an access bowl.
If there was to be 8 total bowls in the CFP I think that makes it hard for Las Vegas considering that would make 3/8 out west. Better to go with San Antonio.
Gator hasn't been significant in a long time. Tampa is a good semifinal site. That leaves the Citrus Bowl in Florida as a game that could step up.
A: Rose, Cotton, Sugar, Orange
B: Fiesta, Alamo, Peach, Citrus
Rotate the two groups for the quarterfinals. Give the 7th and 8th highest rated conference champions access bowls to protect the P5 in case a conference is having an off year.
Also protects the 11th and 12th rated CFP teams should it be a Northwestern or Wake Forest from having to drop down to a lower pecking order bowl if they don't make the playoff since they don't have enough fans and might get bumped to the Military bowl. They should get rewarded for having a really good season.