(01-07-2016 02:08 PM)Owl 69/70/75 Wrote: [ -> ]Rhoades's first year was better than Bailiff's first year.
Bailiff's second year was far better than Rhoades's second year so far.
But improvement in athletics is seldom linear. I'm okay with a step back this year if we make a huge step forward next year.
I expect that Rhoades's third year will turn out to be substantially better than Bailiff's third year. If not, then I would expect Rhoades to get the same level of scrutiny and criticism that we have imposed on Bailiff. That seems eminently fair to me.
I'll reply to this here.
I do keep in mind that Rhoades inherited a team at the very bottom from Braun, a head Coach at the end of his career, who shifted gears into broadcasting the next season, who called some of his successor's games as an announcer, and who admitted on air a few times that Coach Rhoades was getting more out of the players Braun recruited that he did. Braun I believe is still a supporter of both Rice and of Coach Rhoades, which is nice to see it has seemingly worked out well for everyone so far.
Here's how Rhoades compares so far to Rice's recent Men's Basketball Head Coaches going back to the last time we were in the NCAAs, 1970:
Code:
Don Knodel 1966-1974 76-127 .374
Bob Polk 1974-1977 17-63 .212
Mike Schuler 1977-1981 30-76 .283
Tommy Suitts 1981-1987 64-106 .376
Scott Thompson 1987-1992 65-79 .451
Willis Wilson 1992-2008 219-246 .471
Ben Braun 2008-2014 63-128 .330
Mike Rhoades 2014-pres 17-30 .362
So, despite the poor start again this season, Rhoades is still doing better than Coach Braun so far. Braun had the following records in his first two years:
BB 2008-09 10-22 .312
BB 2009-10 8-23 .258
BB first 2 years: 18-45 .286
In Wilson's first two seasons, keep in mind he inherited a program that had already been rehabilitated by his predecessor, Scott Thompson, who chose not to stick around to see it through:
WTW 1992-93 18-10 .643
WTW 1993-94 15-14 .517
WTW first 2 years: 33-24 .578
Scott Thompson, who came in after Tommy Suitts/Greg Walcavich had gone 8-19 in 1986-1987 (see, Rice has gotten rid of a coach mid-season!) inherited a real dumpster fire. Autry Court was old and unairconditioned. The locker room facilities were as bad or worse than the present football locker room is reported to be. Thompson had the school spend upfront to renovate the basketball locker room before his first season started.
Thompson turned the negative of Rice's unairconditioned gym into a fearsome asset, by encouraging the "Jungle Gym" theme and atmosphere amongst his players, fans and running with the moniker bestowed by the DMN writer who so dubbed it. Getting a suspended floor to help prevent injuries was, in my opinion, far more important to helping the Owls than the air conditioning, which was more for fan comfort, but skewed to the Owls' advantage when hosting opponents who were not used to it.
Thompson, starting from basically ground zero (he had inherited D'Wayne Tanner, Andy Gilchrist and an injured Glenn Youngkin, of Youngkin center fame) and had brought in his first freshman class of David Willie and Chip Scott) had the following record his first two years here:
ST 1987-88 6-21 .222
ST 1988-89 12-16 .428
ST first two years: 18-37 .327
Okay, turning to the B word:
I do keep in mind that the Bword inherited a team somewhat rehabilitated and on the way up, fresh off a bowl season from Todd Graham. It was Todd Graham that inherited the team at the very bottom (1-11) from Hatfield and had to do a lot of heavy lifting to change a culture that had grown quite stagnant in many ways....Hatfield, who despite some very successful (by then Rice standards) seasons that would have already put Rice in several bowl games if there had been the bloated number of lesser bowls there have been this past decade, with 3 winning seasons against a higher level of competition overall for much of his career here at Rice, including a co-SWC Conference Championship in 1994. Graham was a head Coach at the very beginning of his career, who shifted gears (and schools) into becoming a Top 10 head football coach at a P5 school, where he remains (so far) today. I'm not saying I wish he was still here. I am saying we really needed a guy like him to shake us up at the time, and we could use one again now, in my opinion.
Graham's 2006 Rice team was 7-6 that season, including the bowl loss to Troy in the New Orleans bowl, Rice's first bowl appearance in decades since the 1961 BlueBonnet Bowl at Rice Stadium in 1961. Graham, for all his travels, has had just 2 losing seasons so far in his entire 10-year coaching career, one more year than Coach Bword. Graham has gone to 9 bowl games in those 10 years. Bword has gone to just 4 in his 9 years so far.
Here's how Bailiff compares so far to Rice's recent Men's Football Head Coaches going back to the last time we were really relevant nationally in football, around the early 1960s:
Code:
David Bailiff 2007–pres 53–60 .469
Todd Graham 2006 7–6 .538
Ken Hatfield 1994–2005 55–78–1 .410
Fred Goldsmith 1989-93 23–31–1 .427
Jerry Berndt 1986-88 6–27–0 .182
Watson Brown 1984-85 4–18–0 .182
Ray Alborn 1978-83 13–53–0 .197
Homer Rice 1976-77 4–18–0 .182
Al Conover 1972-75 14–28–2 .341
Bill Peterson 1971 3–7–1 .318
Bo Hagan 1967-70 12–27–1 .313
Jess Neely 1940-66 144–124–10 .536
So, we can chew on some of those numbers and comparisons.
If anyone deserves the benefit of the doubt, from the get-go, it would be Coach Goldsmith in football, and Coaches Rhodes, Thompson, and Braun (who inherited a real mess from Wilson's end and after the season-in-the-wilderness, remember) and Coach Graham in baseball.
Bailiff inherited a relative plumb by Rice standards not by national football standards. He did raise the level somewhat, has been on a roller-coaster with varying hills and valleys his decade here, and has Rice more or less back to basically where the program was after Graham left 10 years ago when Bailiff started here.
That will hopefully explain to some of you why I am so far still very enamored with Coach Rhoades and what he is doing, despite the present record, and why I have long since given up on the Bword doing much beyond what he has already accomplished here.
Now, I agree with Owl69 above, if Coach Rhodes is tanking it in 3 to 4 years, with his own recruits and a chance to establish his style, system and assistants of his choice here, I'll be getting my basketball pitchfork out as well. At this point, I feel my basketball pitchfork will collect a lot of rust in storage before it is needed again in basketball.
And this season is not over yet in basketball. Though it looks a bit more difficult so far than last year where he could rely on the senior leadership of leftovers Gearhart and Peera (who Rhoades helped transform into
playas by his coaching) I still hold out hope our basketball team will improve this season. But, I have said before, the way it has played out, this looks like another season 1. Next year we should see some better improvement with a bit more depth and more of Rhoades' own recruits, not to mention Lott and Jackson hopefully back and no worse for the wear of their difficult injuries (fingers crossed).
Meantime, I just want to see more defensive effort and hands up instead of at their sides, and more movement w/o the ball on offense to improve the flow. The per-game scoring average appears to be trending up in the right direction. One more solid player available would have made a huge difference in basketball so far in my opinion.
In football it would take a lot more than just one player, and I'm not sold that coach Bword knows how to use them as effectively to maximize their potential with what he has shown this past decade here. My gut feeling and eyeball observation is that our football players win games in spite of our system as much as because of it. In other words, they battle the opponent and their own coaching each game. Not so in basketball, in my opinion, so far. I think this years' basketball team would be worse with either Braun or Wilson (or Walchovich/Suitts) at this point.
All just my opinions. Agree or disagree if you wish.
*btw: lining up all that data, even with using the 'code' command, is still a real pain. Why does the spacing still space out, and is there an easier way to get it right w/o individually space-barring things each item? I seem to recall we used to have a sticky on posting tricks and how-to advice on this board, but it was removed a few years ago. Thanks.