(01-25-2023 10:17 AM)BigBlueMonarch Wrote: With the number of male students attending college as a whole declining and campuses becoming 60%, or more in some cases, female is the math for Title IX compliance changing?
Prong 1 (Proportionality) is not the only way a school can comply. With the addition of VB, that gives the school a bit of a break from being under the microscope from any inquiries as it can cite Prong 2 (adding opportunities for the underrepresented gender). Prong 1 was the easy way out when the OCR (Office of Civil Rights) started fielding more complaints in the 1990s. When Norma Cantu listed Prong 1 as a "safe harbor," then you started to see a lot of math being done to manipulate rosters and bodies, such as the extensive report USA Today released last year about how schools are still fudging the numbers to appear as if they are proportional. She's long been gone, but that action 25+ years ago is the policy most current ADs came to understand when they were getting into the business. It's what they were taught and in turn, it's how they teach the next generation.
When Liberty dropped wrestling, it cited they were going to comply with Prong 1, even though they clearly had a viable defense with Prong 2. Their issue? They added too many women's sports too fast. Had they spaced them out with a new one every five years, they could have continued to meet Prong 2 for another decade-plus. They came up on a situation (they created) where they were going to be open to a suit if they didn't drop a sport to get in line with Prong 1 despite adding numerous women's sports. Poor leadership. Lack of forward thinking.
This law has been on the books for 50 years and really been applied staunchly to college athletics since 1979, and again in 1996 (I use those dates because of the precedent rulings or clarifications listed were set). It's part of the job and one you can't just put a band-aid on or half-ass to try to actually do it right before getting into more issues down the road.
Any AD who creates a Title IX issue on their watch in this day and age - is FAILING at a key part of their job - and the easy way out for poor leadership has been to axe students who had nothing to do with those failures. "Oh, it's Title IX's fault," they say. - No, it's not. It's your fault. We're 30 years beyond the "Oh, I didn't know" excuse.
Beach Volleyball is an add that makes sense for ODU, the problem is, if/when it gets added, it won't be done for the reasons it should be. This hasn't been a progressive athletic department for a long time.