(06-25-2017 01:23 PM)CougarRed Wrote: It's certainly true, for example, that Temple's numbers were boosted by home games with Penn St and Notre Dame in 2015.
But BYU's numbers are boosted by home games vs P5 teams too. Mississippi State was by far their biggest TV draw last year.
BYU's TV numbers are going to be more consistent than American schools by virtue of how the contracts are structured. BYU gets 4-5 home telecasts per year guaranteed. The American works on 10-day windows. So the teams who perform well get better TV opportunities (including some ABC games which BYU does not get). UCF had great ratings in 2013 when they won the Fiesta Bowl. Not so great in 2015 when they went 0-12.
Over a 10 year stretch, playing the same home schedule as BYU and having the exact same time slots and channels as BYU, I think the several American teams who had consistent football success in that 10 year window would draw as well or better than BYU in terms of TV viewers. The teams not having football success would draw worse.
These bolded statements almost feel like intentional misdirection. Since you pulled the numbers you should know that BYU only had 4 games in each of 2015 and 2016 on ESPN stations where they would draw a viewer rating and of those 8 games only 2 were against P5 competition.
To be upfront, here are the opponents and time slots/channel for BYU's previous 2 seasons of home games (all times eastern):
2016
UCLA - 10:45 PM - ESPN2 - 746k
Toledo - 11:01 PM - ESPN2 - 579k
Mississippi St - 10:16 PM - ESPN - 1.475m
Utah State - 10:25 PM - ESPNU - 320k
Southern Utah and UMass were both on BYUtv/ESPN3.
2015
Boise State - 10:15 PM - ESPN2 - 1.027m
UConn - 10:15 PM - ESPN2 - 1.240m
East Carolina - 7:30 PM - ESPNU - 273k
Cincinnati - 8:00 PM - ESPN - 1.468m
Wagner was on BYUtv and Fresno State on BYUtv/ESPN3.
= 7.128m for 8 games
Here is the apples-to-apples comparison as I can see for Houston:
2016
UConn - 7:55 PM - ESPN - 1.421k
UCF - 12:00 PM - ESPNU - 192k
Tulane - 7:20 PM - ESPN2 - 454k
Louisville - 7:55 PM - ESPN - 2.432
Not counted is Lamar which did not pull ratings and the Oklahoma game @ NRG stadium which drew a 5.713m rating.
2015
SMU - 8:00 PM - ESPN2 - 356k
Vanderbilt - 7:00 PM - ESPN2 - 392k
Cincinnati - 3:30 PM - ESPN2 - 396k
Memphis - 7:05 PM - ESPN2
Navy - 12:00 PM - ABC - 3.055
Not counted is Tenessee Tech and Texas State which did not pull ratings.
= 9.446m for 9 games
So if you add in the Oklahoma game in an NFL stadium and call it a "home" game, that bumps the number up to 15.159m. I'm not sure how you came up to 17.6m for your Houston number using numbers from that website unless you are adding in a bowl game or something.