(04-11-2018 07:14 AM)JMURocks Wrote: (04-10-2018 11:07 PM)bjk3047 Wrote: (04-09-2018 07:55 AM)JMU_Degenerate Wrote: Finishing top 3 in the CAA gets you into the playoffs... playing Thanksgiving weekend... in front of 13,000 fans... in a spot that JMU has shown is tough to win in consistently.
Finishing undefeated in OOC (regardless of level of play of your opponents) gives you a chance at a seed and a bye week.
You scheduled to make the playoffs. We all know this to be true and I am happy to hear Kevin White admit it.
I know I'm late to this, but +100000
I think there's a difference of opinion as to whether the goal should be 'competing' within the regular season, or positioning yourself for 'competing' as far into the playoffs as possible.
Personally, it's not close for me. At least as long as we're FCS, you play for championships. Feeling decent about the overall level of competition within conference (for fan engagement), the ends 100% justify the means for playing OOC cupcakes.
Yep, while it would be nice to see stronger opponents sometimes, this is how you maximize your chances at hosting and winning in the playoffs.
The committee has shown they don't really respect SoS as much as they should (see the high seeds awarded the SLC), and NDSU has followed a similar OOC scheduling philosophy for years (one FBS or strong FCS and two cupcakes). Every win improves your odds for a high seed (though an FBS loss doesn't tend to hurt much). In the playoffs home field advantage is huge, its contributed to NDSU's success, and previously helped other schools like Montana and Marshall during their peak.
And they've maintained at least 6 home games every season. JMU is doing 5 home games about once every 3 seasons (2011, 2014, 2018).
12 games allowed I think 3 out of every 11 years. I believe the pattern is back to back 12 game seasons allowed, then 4 seasons of 11 games, then a season of 12 allowed, then then 4 seasons of 11 games, repeat. I believe the 12 game seasons allowed were 2002, 2003, 2008, 2013, 2014, 2019..I know 2008 JMU only scheduled 11...
It shouldn't be that difficult to:
-maintain 6 home games every season as NDSU does.
-play a quality I-AA as part of a home and home every season.
-at least 1 cupcake every season,
-a I-A close to 2/3 of seasons if you can continue to find ones willing to schedule.
11 game seasons:
Season 1: 6 home games. OOC: @ I-A, home vs quality I-AA, home vs cupcake
Season 2: 6 home games. OOC: @ quality I-AA, home vs cupcake, home vs cupcake
Repeat.
12 game seasons:
6 home games: @ I-A, @ quality I-AA, home vs cupcake, home vs cupcake
or
7 home games: @ I-A, home vs quality I-AA, home vs cupcake, home vs cupcake.
Now NDSU went from playing a I-A every season after they moved up to a 5 season stretch 2015-2019 only 1 (@ Iowa 2016). Do have @ Oregon 2020. This I believe is due to difficulty finding even P5 willing to play them. This happens after winning 6 straight over I-A/5 straight over P-5. Apparently JMU is starting to face this same problem to a lesser extent.