Captain Bearcat
All-American in Everything
Posts: 9,501
Joined: Jun 2010
Reputation: 768
I Root For: UC
Location: IL & Cincinnati, USA
|
RE: Cincinnati Enquirer on expansion.
(02-15-2016 06:12 PM)jaredf29 Wrote: (02-15-2016 05:34 PM)Captain Bearcat Wrote: (02-15-2016 03:09 PM)jaredf29 Wrote: (02-15-2016 12:19 PM)Captain Bearcat Wrote: (02-14-2016 02:32 PM)DavidSt Wrote:
But, almost everybody in the AAC, C-USA, MAC, MWC, Sun Belt and FCS cover almost all 5.
This isn't even close to true.
Cincinnati has more living alumni than almost every non-Big 10 school in the nation. With 285,000 living alums, we dwarf USF & UCF (both of which were tiny schools 30 years ago) and every other G5 school except SDSU and UConn. USF & UCF might be bigger in the future, but with 43,700 students and a higher graduation rate than them we're currently graduating more students every year.
When it comes to academic success measures, UC is ahead of every G5 school except Rice, although UConn, Temple and CSU are about at our level. Everyone else except Tulane, USF, SMU, and SDSU isn't even close.
Our recruiting and market size aren't too shabby either, so no one except Houston & SMU has a big advantage over us in that regard.
Now these might not be the metrics that the conferences are looking at. For example, Louisville only has about 110,000 living alums and they got picked. But if these are the right metrics, Cincinnati is the clear #1 choice.
You are in fact not graduating more students than UCF, idk about USF but I'd assume that is also untrue. Your market is currently ranked #36, so there are several schools that are ahead you in that regard including USF, Houston, UCF, UCONN, SMU, and Temple. http://www.tvb.org/media/file/2015-2016-dma-ranks.pdf
We also know your line about living alumni is false, so all in all you've firmly discredited yourself.
Cincinnati:
"There are 285,000 living alumni of the University of Cincinnati. Whether we're old friends or have yet to meet, we all share a common Bearcat bond."
https://www.alumni.uc.edu/
UCF:
"The FAIRWINDS Alumni Center welcomes many of our 250,000 UCF alumni"
http://www.ucf.edu/alumni-giving/
Unless one of these schools is lying on their website, Cincinnati has more living alumni than UCF has total alumni.
And I never said our market was #1. I said that it's "not too shabby."
Time for a fact check on alumni #'s.
South Florida 290,000
Cincinnati 285,000
San Diego State 280,000
Central Florida 250,000
Buffalo 230,000
Connecticut 230,000
Houston 224,000
Kent State 214,000
Colorado State 200,000
San Jose State 200,000
Miami U. 200,000
Western Michigan 185,000
While UC is near the top of alumni numbers among G5 schools it hardly dwarfs anyone in the G5 beyond the private schools.
The claim that UC dwarfs alumni of non-B1G schools is also false. I don't have all the numbers but one site that has the Top 50 networks (a list that UC is squarely not a part of).
NYU 470,000
UCLA 400,000
Florida 367,000
Texas A&M 370,000
Southern Cal 366,000
Columbia 300,000
North Carolina 300,000
Georgia 300,000
Auburn 200,000
John's Hopkins 190,000
Emory 133,000
Princeton 90,000
http://www.bestcollegevalues.org/top-alumni-networks/
Credit to Kittonhead, you should also prove where you said that you're putting out more alumni than UCF and USF. You can certainly disagree on whether UC is top choice or even a better choice, not disputing either assertion just your "facts". You wrote no one but SMU and Houston have an advantage over UC in market, clearly not the case.
I stand corrected about USF. I wasn't able to find theirs when I looked this up a few years ago and just lumped them into the same category as UCF. In that light, USF also would be a strong candidate according to those criteria.
There's over 340 schools in D-1 and 7000 in the country. UC has more living alums than all but 1 Big 12 school (Texas), all but 3 ACC schools (FSU, UNC, and Pitt), and all but 3 SEC schools (Florida, Georgia, Texas A&M). I didn't bother checking the PAC (it took me a long, long time to find this data). And it doesn't surprise me that there's one or two non-FBS schools out there (NYU, Columbia).
So please stop putting words in my (and other posters') mouth. I said, "Cincinnati has more living alumni than almost every non-Big 10 school in the nation." This is a true statement. Even with your extensive searches you only found 8.
Also, I said, "Our recruiting and market size aren't too shabby either, so no one except Houston & SMU has a big advantage over us in that regard." I did not say, "no one but SMU and Houston have an advantage over UC in market," as you claim I said.
So while you nitpick at details which cast your school in a poor light, you're still forgetting the primary point: if you just pick each individual category, Cincy is at or near the top or on the top of the G5 pile in every one. UCF certainly can't claim that because academics is one of the categories.
|
|