(11-06-2015 01:27 PM)Antarius Wrote: We were 74 in Sagarin when we went 5-6 in the 90's. We won 10 games in 2013 and were #69.
That summarizes exactly why 10 win seasons aren't the be all and end all and how you can be a mediocre coach and still rack up 10 wins against the dregs.
Yep, life in the G5 is hard, especially when we are talking about doing anything with your Sagarin ranking, regardless of . Inevitably, playing enough G5 teams over the course of the season does little to elevate your Sagarin ranking (which is used, primarily because it is easy to search).
Looking at 2014, Marshall was the highest rated G5 at #23 (which is surprising given that they beat no one) and then it was Louisiana Tech at #34 (after #32 NDSU interestingly enough), and then Boise State (#46) and Memphis (#39) rounding out the Top 40. So I think that helps illustrate the difficulty of breaking into the Top 40 as a G5 - just 10% of the teams in the Top 40 were G5s, and none were in the Top 20.
But I think more telling is 2013. In the first non-P5 was NDSU (#17 - Woh!) and then UCF at #25. That is the same UCF that beat AP ranked teams in Baylor (#9 in Sagarin) in the Fiesta Bowl and Louisville (#20 in Sagarin), and only lose to ranked South Carolina (#10 in Sagarin) by 3. I think that helps illustrate how hard it is to do much of anything as a G5 in Sagarin rankings.
The next G5 is Bowling Green, down at #39. So only two G5s in the Top 40 (excluding FCS teams). Other G5 teams above us in 2013 included: Utah State (#41), Houston (#50), Navy (#51), Fresno State (#54), NIU (#59), Marshall (#61), UNT (#63), Cinci (#67), and Toledo (#68).