(03-24-2014 02:58 PM)ivet Wrote: (03-24-2014 12:21 PM)uconnwhaler Wrote: We would be more of a mis-matched sock in the now Catholic-only Big East. I have actually heard from some G-Town friends that there is some unhappiness for G-Town in the NBE, is that true, or just a small sample size?
As an aside, UConn just ran through its ticket allotment and many many high donors were not able to get any tickets and are now also flooding secondary markets - didn't think it was possible but prices will probably continue to rise as the week wears on.
I work at Georgetown, that is not true. We are more concerned with Academic profiles and institutional fit than number of championships a school has. Why do you think Richmond is even mentioned as a candidate? As this recent tournament has shown, small time programs are well capable of knocking out the Blue Bloods in the tournament. We are more concerned with the stability and longevity of the BE and not have to worry about Conference shuffling again.
This is a fool's errand. Every Eastern conference except the SEC, Ivy, and Big 10 has had a member leave over the past 5 years. Even conferences of like-minded institutions like the MVC and ACC have lost members. What makes the current Big East resistant to those changes?
Maybe if you had added Notre Dame instead of Butler, you'd have the religious affiliation thing going. Or if Dayton and ND had joined, Georgetown would have some academic equals in the conference. But as it is, the conference spans from Rhode Island to Nebraska, with enrollments from 4,600 (Butler and Providence) to 25,000 + (Depaul and St. John's), with missions ranging from regional, undergraduate-focus (XU, Providence, Villanova, Butler) to high-end professional commuter schools (Depaul, St. John's) to national research institutions of widely varying quality. Ten years ago the schools were in 5 different conferences.
That doesn't shout "Unity!" to me. At least, not on a level that makes the conference more stable than other top-end basketball conferences.
IMO, Georgetown is the most desirable school for other conferences to add, but St. John's and Creighton also have attractive options that don't require another school to jump with them. Put another way, the conference is only stable as long as those 3 schools want it to be. They may be united now, but a new administration at any of those schools could change their mind and destabilize the whole conference.
*edit - I hope they do stay together and I'm rooting for them. I just don't see them being any more committed than other schools that have made similar professions of unity in the past.