RE: Did Miami screw up by leaving the BE?
Since I do not live in Florida, it is hard for me to tell someone who does who has more fans, or who can own a market in 20 year. But I do know that about six or seven years ago, Miami was the clear number one in the state on the field, FSU was two, and UF was a distant third. So I can't see how Florida has such a stranglehold on the state, other than FSU and Miami basically appearing over the last 30 years.
That said, the fact that FSU and Miami really only became national powers about 30 years ago, and are one of only a handful of teams that joined the big boy club in that time, and stayed, it does create hope for the future of USF, and UCF.
On the field, I think Miami's troubles came from three fronts.
1) The Big East that Miami left was really, really bad. The teams have improved a lot since then, but Miami and Va. Tech really owned the conference, and there were a lot of cupcakes. When they left along with VT, and BC, they joined FSU, Clemson, and Maryland (who was riding high at the time) who were also used to playing a lot of cupcakes. I just don’t think any of those teams were prepared for the serious upswing in competition they would face.
2) After taking the first scenario into account, a newly BCS South Florida, combined with new coaches at Louisville, West Virginia, and Pittsburgh who started heavily recruiting Miami’s territory, and getting some good talent to boot, eroded some of the depth that Miami used to have. They still had their top shelf talent, but those backups that used to give them invaluable depth and make them impervious to injuries, suspensions, etc, were now playing at other schools
3) Bobby Petrino. Call me a homer, but I swear I remember Miami having a vaunted defense that no one could master. Then in 2004, in a losing effort, Petrino’s Conference USA Louisville Cardinals sliced up Miami’s defense, and were up by 3 touchdowns, and would have beaten them in Miami, if not for the team celebrating and stopping playing as they thought the game was over. Then there was that damn dropped interception by Kerry Rhodes. In any event, after that game, Miami lost 3 of their next four or five, because all of a sudden teams that could never score on them had seen a blueprint on how to shred their defense. Once that happened, it exposed the offense, and started their downward fall
That’s my story, and I’m sticking to it.
|