Unfortunately, Oregon St. was 9-4 last year. 2006. We're talking about this year where Oregon St. couldn't decide on a QB and were giving up yards like crazy while Utah still had its starting QB and RB in the opener (QB is out a couple weeks, RB is out for season).
Unfortunately you're wrong, Oregon State went 10-4 last year. 2006
http://oregonstate.rivals.com/schedule.a...year=2006. And we're talking about this year, Oregon State returns a lot of players from last year's team. This is from the Oregon State website:
When the team returns to the field in April it will be back to business for a club that returns 61 lettermen and 17 starters as it aims for the program’s fifth bowl game in six years.
And where are these "crazy yards" you claim Utah was piling up, because they only scored 7 points. If you use the excuse that they were injured early then how do you know they were piling up crazy yards, because it would have to be insane yardage. And if they got hurt later in the game they should have been able to put up more then 7 points. The QB was on pace to throw for 235 yards, hardling piling up the yards like crazy. He left at the half. Virginia is a crappy team. Oregon State would wipe the floor with them.
Oregon St. and Virginia are similar, in that both could really suck this year. I'm not crapping on Cincy's win. Its a big win. I'm not sure that Wyoming couldn't have done the same at home, nor that you wouldn't have done the same to Virginia.
Oregon State has a bowl quality team this year, as evident of their dismantling of Utah. Virginai flats out sucks and has sucked for the last few years. No disrespect matt, but anybody who thinks that Virginia is as good as Oregon State doesn't know anything about football. Let me help you out though, UC WOULD have dismantled Virginia at home. This the same UC team that destroyed USF, Rutgers and Oregon State at home 3 of the last 4 home games. All three teams are bowl teams and Top 25 caliber teams (with Rutgers and Oregon State finishing the season ranked and USF finishing with 9 wins and a road win against a Top 10 team). Meanwhile, as I have informed you, Virginia is 1-4 OOC including getting dismantled by non-BCS teams ECU and Wyoming. Virginia has been terrible for years, they have a proven track record of that. So, in conclusion, you're completely wrong. Virginia is a crappy team and not that big a deal when it comes to quality, Oregon State is a big deal and a quality win.
Notre Dame was a BCS team last year and so was Michigan. How much is a victory over either worth today?
I don't know, were they receiving Top 25 votes? I believe they were so Oregon and Penn State got a big boost from them. I would say that both of those teams are better then Virginia. Would you consider a victory over those schools equal to beating a crappy Virginia squad?
[b]As far as the Receiving Votes portion of the poll, Texas Tech has too many votes, Arizona St. not enough. I think that's due to folks not waiting up until close to 2am to see Arizona St. beat Colorado by 19.