dark horse

I cant think of anyone else who came out of nowhere to win the MVP. Did anyone see this coming?

Personally, I thought Jeter had it in the bag.

Terpy Wrote:dark horse

I cant think of anyone else who came out of nowhere to win the MVP. Did anyone see this coming?

Personally, I thought Jeter had it in the bag.

i did. i voted for him on espn.com's poll. in fact, i had him pegged as the mvp ages ago.

I didnt realize he was second in the AL in RBI, but still I think I would have had him third behind Jeter and Big Papi.

He is good but has a lesser known player won the MVP before?

Terpy Wrote:I didnt realize he was second in the AL in RBI, but still I think I would have had him third behind Jeter and Big Papi.

He is good but has a lesser known player won the MVP before?

why papi? the award is most valuable.

Please, Morneau was great but he wasnt even the most valuable player on his own team.

Papi was the most valuable on his team, so he is ahead of Morneau in my book right there.

Terpy Wrote:Please, Morneau was great but he wasnt even the most valuable player on his own team.

Papi was the most valuable on his team, so he is ahead of Morneau in my book right there.

you probably didn't recognize, but the twins began getting hot and making their playoff push at exactly the same time that morneau got hot.

besides, papi is a DH. They shouldn't win the MVP.

Doesnt matter, they wouldnt have sniffed the playoffs if it werent for Santana.

Terpy Wrote:Doesnt matter, they wouldnt have sniffed the playoffs if it werent for Santana.

same thing for morneau.

I guess we will have to agree to disagree on that.

Terpy Wrote:I guess we will have to agree to disagree on that.

isn't that what we do on everything?

Terpy Wrote:Personally, I thought Jeter had it in the bag.

I think everyone seemed to think that. But can you be a MVP, when you know if the person misses the whole season, they still make the playoffs?

chris_young Wrote:

Terpy Wrote:Personally, I thought Jeter had it in the bag.

I think everyone seemed to think that. But can you be a MVP, when you know if the person misses the whole season, they still make the playoffs?

once again, i didn't think that.

are you saying the yankees would've made the playoffs without jeter?