with no great starter, maybe it could go to a closer

TailgateTiger Wrote:with no great starter, maybe it could go to a closer

maybe, but not an overrated one.

flyingswoosh Wrote:

TailgateTiger Wrote:with no great starter, maybe it could go to a closer

maybe, but not an overrated one.

he had a bad start of the season, still not as many blown saves as hoffman. Mets lead the Majors in one run wins ;-)

flyingswoosh Wrote:

TailgateTiger Wrote:with no great starter, maybe it could go to a closer

maybe, but not an overrated one.

he had a bad start of the season, still not as many blown saves as hoffman. Mets lead the Majors in one run wins ;-)

he's a very good closer, but i think people often overrate him because he throws so hard.

REC 3-2 | SV 39 | ERA 2.08 | WHIP 1.05 / IP 69.1/ SO 89


those are some numbers

I dont think a closer should ever get a Cy Young, the save is the most overrated stat in the history of baseball, but that is just me.

Even in a year where there are no dominant starters a good starter is infinitely more valuable than a closer, I would probably go with whoever ends up with more wins out of Carpenter or Webb.

I agree 100%

I would say it's a toss up between Carpenter, Webb, and Oswalt right now. Whoever pitches the best til the end of the season will get it.

Terpy Wrote:I dont think a closer should ever get a Cy Young, the save is the most overrated stat in the history of baseball, but that is just me.

Even in a year where there are no dominant starters a good starter is infinitely more valuable than a closer, I would probably go with whoever ends up with more wins out of Carpenter or Webb.

yup

TT, I know you are a huge Mets fan but come on!!