Motown Bronco Wrote:Klutz...
Per your overall question, "Is the USA the greatest nation on earth", it seems more subjective than anything. With all its many faults, I think the USA is the greatest country for me. To put it rather simplistically, it has the greatest amount of the summation of personal and economic freedoms. To someone who prefers a more centralized/less individualistic society, then I really wouldn't expect them to say America.
I highly doubt your claim that "most Americans are lazy". I would've even understood if you said 'aggressive' or 'workaholic'. But lazy? Are you sure about that (compared to other countries)?
Per your sports examples... In other countries, they just don't yell and shout the occasional obscenity. People are hurt and killed. When Columbia lost to USA in the World Cup in 1994, they killed one of the players for allowing the last American goal. European soccer riots of yesteryear make college campus riots look tame by comparison.
Did you know a drunken crowd in attendance at the Mexico-USA soccer game in Monterrey chanted/mocked "Osama!" as the losing USA team left the field after the game? Now, who is cruel and mean again?
Now, I'm not the most optimistic person in the world. I can have a pretty dour overview about certain aspects of society. But what I notice from you, klutz, is an over-the-top pessimism. A nihilistic view that almost borders on unhealthiness. I mean, "most people are cruel, mean, brutish and nasty"? Because some jerk cut you off on the freeway, or some obnoxious little league dad hollared at the coach, doesn't mean that we are the Great Satan. Yes, there are a-holes out there you'll run into every day, but welcome to the Planet Earth. You'll get a certain degree of road rage, rudeness, snobiness, thuggary, and brutish behavior at every corner of the globe. Not just America. In your day-to-day life, I recommend just befriending those who you find friendly and down to earth, and simply avoid those who are. Freedom of association is a good thing.
Motown,
I didn't say the USA is the Great Satan, whatever that is.
I'm healthy, had the prostate reamed the other day, boy was that fun! :D
Would you consider it healthy to point out the big purple elephant in the room or ignore it and hope it goes away?
The real pessimist avoids confrontation and tells themselves that everything is okay, whereas the optimist points out problems, whether these are political, social, personal, organizational, etc. Only by identifying a problem can the problem be solved. Simply saying Americans are great, a great people in a great culture represents the real pessimism because those comments aren't qualified, aren't criticized and 'great' is left undefined.
Sports and road examples were merely the first off the top of my head. I have a gazillion more. I will preface the following comments by letting you know that I am a sports reporter and photographer, I must be around insane sports fans who are entirely consumed in the game. I do avoid these folks, but it would be disingenuous of me to not say something to a parent (and business owner) that he/she is embarrassing themselves (sometimes the umps kick them out, one time an alderman refused to leave and the game was suspended until the cops came and exited him from the park, the next day he offered a public apology only to act the same way two weeks later. All for a 12 and Under softball league). Signs posted on the parks' entrances in my locality ban fireworks, alcohol, drugs and profanity, but many of the fine-upstanding representatives of the community violate one or more of these rules every day little league/youth sports is going on.
My sports examples were, however, those sports in which the participants are in the beginning and basic stage. For parents of other participants to be so brutish toward children of other teams represents a special kind of nastiness that is much more nasty than fan behavior at World Cup soccer events, NCAA football, or NFL for that matter. I intentionally did not include those examples because the object of the beration are adults who are used to it and are, generally, professionals who must perform to their utmost ability.
Children as young as 8, 10, 12, maybe even as old as 14 don't realize that the adults berating them don't really mean it. For many, I think this nastiness directed at very young athletes conveys to the children that sports and athletics aren't games after all, but athletics is what really, really matters--more than ethics, God, school and family. (that's a stretch, I know, but we are a gaming society)
Also, the continual barage of cheating accusations directed at umpires and other little league/youth sports officials represents some level of individualism, such as "my kid and my family at-large can do no wrong and for you to call him out on that pop-up to the shortstop shows you are intentionally cheating my kid out of his RBI-double, you fat alchoholic slob who's wife is a whore..."
So Americans are much like other people in other nations, I thought your thesis was Americans are great, greater than the people of any other nation, but you say other nations have people just like those of the USA. By that answer, either the people of the USA are great, and all other nations' people are as well, or the USA does not have great people (for the most part) just like the people of all other nations suck, too.
I would say most Americans are entirely individualistic. Ever notice many cars in the HOV lane during rush hour? I don't, but I don't blame them, I wouldn't want to carpool to work anyway.
There's another form of individualism in many American communities. In my community, currently, the county is growing by leaps and bounds. Since I've lived here in central MS, we've had a 14% increase in population in the county in less than 7 months. For the calendar year 2002-03 the county population increased from 125,000 (give or take) to 132,000 (+, not less than 132K). The population explosion (known as 'white flight') here caused a very large high school to have to split off because the state mandates a certain amount of kids per school. Today that same school is over its limit by 500+ students. The school that was created in 2002 to offset the population increases is now over its limit by about 400+ students. Getting that school bond was an uphill battle all the way, and now the county is embroiled in another bond issue for another new school.
At meetings to discuss the bond issue, many county taxpayers show up and say "I don't have any kids in the school system, so fock them kids--make 'em go to school in those trailers, they don't need no stinkin' air conditioning. We walked to school in the snow back in 1925!." Another large contingent send their kids to Jackson, MS private schools (out-of-county) and consequently they oppose the bond issue. At meetings they say "if everyone sent their kids to Prep, then we wouldn't need a new school." The parents moving into the county can't afford the property rates, much less the boo-coodles of dollars in tuition at Prep or JA!
In the possibility that local taxes are reduced (won't happen here in the near future, but it has happened here in the past) then at community board and supervisors' meetings you'll see John Q. Public in there raising cain "how's my kid going to throw for 3,000 career yards if the school district doesn't have enough money to pony up for some new footballs and a contract for Billy Pocket Passer Smith, the new QB coach for the Mustangs?" Likewise, today at meetings you got fat-cat rich-arse parents who are misty-eyed that one schools' students decided to start a lacrosse program. Currently it gets no state or local funding, but Sally Q. Public is raising cain "my little Sally needs a new lacrosse helmet and and new field because soccer can't be played on the football field. You're telling me you're going to use MY tax dollars to build a new school???"
It's always me, me, me, my, my, my. The former gov. of Maine said it best, if Americans want something...well...ain't nothing free, so they better be prepared to pay for it some way or the other.
What these parents and taxpayers need to do, is count their blessings that they even have schools and high school athletics, and clean drinking water and the right to discuss things such as these topics with county officials.
Much individualism is espoused on this forum, i.e. don't take my money away and give it crack-smoking mothers who want to have gov. funded abortions!! On the Left, they say "don't take my money away so you can bomb Syria or treat G.W. to Pebble Beach greens fees the rest of his life!"
There's also the common theme of "don't tread on me" espoused on this forum, which is a kind of individualism.
Want to see individualism? Wait tables or bartend for a while. I guarantee someone will DEMAND something that is not on the menu, i.e. "waiter, I want the escargeaux in a creme sauce, on a bed of angel hair pasta. Also, I want an ice water with no ice."
Answer: "m'am, we don't serve escargeaux..."
Rebuttal: "are you telling me the customer is WRONG in this establishment????"
Bartender to guest: "what'll you have?"
guest: "a Warsteiner draft and no lip from you!"
Bartender: " the only draft we have is Bud light and Miller light"
guest: "I thought I told you no LIP!!"
In the restaurant biz, you'd be surprised how individualistic those who dine are, not to mention the people who work in restaurants. They are so individualistic, team-work is rarely achieved.
When I said "lazy" Motown, I meant Americans are lazy in that they never try to improve on things in our culture and society and a big example of that would be our continued dependence on oil, gas and the combustible engine inside an SUV when we know full well that we'll be invading nations, and/or, getting suckered by OPEC to keep these things running.
Americans are lazy because a growing number, about 45-48% go to head shrinks and say I have emotional problems-- "give me the drugs"-- or go to the doctor and say "suck this fat off of my thighs, it's too hot to jog regularly."
Americans are comfortable, very much so, and for the most part we don't want to use our muscles or our heads, we want instant gratification. And by gawd, we sure as hell don't want to think about the unsavory characteristics of our great society and culture.
Lastly, you say Planet Earth always presents pot-holes, could one of those pot-holes be that Americans (the people) are by and large nasty a people and we pride ourselves on that, or we simply ignore that aspect to our collective identity? And it wasn't my question, it was the Washington Journal's question, and I repeated it on this thread.
This C-SPAN show can be seen every morning from 6 a.m. (CDT) to 9 a.m.
Motown, I'm an optimist because I can recognize and isolate the problems in my community thus giving me the knowledge that things must change if we're to continue in this greatness we've experienced. I reiterate, the pessimist would call someone in the community like me a "pessimistic" mal-content who loves Stalin and is brooding over spilt milk all day.---Such rhetoric is great and funny, but it does little to solve the problems. The optimist, furthermore, recognizes the problems we are faced with as a people and KNOWS that we CAN get better. Greatness is great, but to stay great we need to work, WORK, at staying great and I know we can do it!!