Murphy and Rimmer are similar in that early during their sophomore season (5 games in for Murphy and 2 games in for Rimmer) they decided to transfer to Florida. The difference is that Rimmer was healthy for his senior season while Murphy played in only 3 games due to injury. Murphy's waiver I believe was to get a second medical redshirt season (he used his first when he missed the entire season due to a concussion his first year on Duke's campus) so in essence he was petitioning to get his senior year back, not his sophomore year when he transferred.