CSNbbs
3 Undrafted Free Agents from One School make 53 man rosters? - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: AACbbs (/forum-460.html)
+---- Forum: Archives (/forum-400.html)
+----- Forum: AACbbs Archives (/forum-418.html)
+------ Forum: Cincinnati Archives (/forum-932.html)
+------ Thread: 3 Undrafted Free Agents from One School make 53 man rosters? (/thread-826190.html)



3 Undrafted Free Agents from One School make 53 man rosters? - dsquare - 09-04-2017 09:03 PM

I wonder if the Cats may have set an obscure record, but it has to be very rare when one school has 3 undrafted free agents make an opening day 53 man Nfl roster. ie. Bond(colts), Green(lions), Wilson(vikings).


RE: 3 Undrafted Free Agents from One School make 53 man rosters? - Ring of Black - 09-05-2017 05:11 AM

I don't know. Good question.

Nevertheless, congrats to them all 04-bow


RE: 3 Undrafted Free Agents from One School make 53 man rosters? - JackieTreehorn - 09-05-2017 06:24 AM

And the only one that got drafted was cut. Go figure.


RE: 3 Undrafted Free Agents from One School make 53 man rosters? - CliftonAve - 09-05-2017 07:51 AM

It is actually easier to get cut as a 6th/7th round draft pick than it is an undrafted free agent. Undrafted free agents receive a three year contract at the league minimum salary. The 6th/7th round pick will get about a $100K more a year plus a signing bonus. Therefore, many teams will cut the low draft pick over the UFA's if there is not a distinguishable difference to get the savings on the salary cap.


RE: 3 Undrafted Free Agents from One School make 53 man rosters? - BearcatMan - 09-05-2017 08:12 AM

(09-05-2017 07:51 AM)CliftonAve Wrote:  It is actually easier to get cut as a 6th/7th round draft pick than it is an undrafted free agent. Undrafted free agents receive a three year contract at the league minimum salary. The 6th/7th round pick will get about a $100K more a year plus a signing bonus. Therefore, many teams will cut the low draft pick over the UFA's if there is not a distinguishable difference to get the savings on the salary cap.

Exactly...and add to it the fact that Seattle wanted Tyson to play a position he hasn't played since his junior year of HS, and it's pretty clear he was on the block.


RE: 3 Undrafted Free Agents from One School make 53 man rosters? - bearcatdp - 09-05-2017 09:25 AM

(09-05-2017 07:51 AM)CliftonAve Wrote:  It is actually easier to get cut as a 6th/7th round draft pick than it is an undrafted free agent. Undrafted free agents receive a three year contract at the league minimum salary. The 6th/7th round pick will get about a $100K more a year plus a signing bonus. Therefore, many teams will cut the low draft pick over the UFA's if there is not a distinguishable difference to get the savings on the salary cap.

They get to keep their signing bonus though. Also, the salary slot of a 6/7th round pick is still pretty close to NFL min. Regardless, RFAs are cheaper, but not much.


RE: 3 Undrafted Free Agents from One School make 53 man rosters? - digibrink - 09-05-2017 07:01 PM

So just by being drafted you make a little income via signing bonus?


RE: 3 Undrafted Free Agents from One School make 53 man rosters? - Bearhawkeye - 09-05-2017 07:47 PM

(09-05-2017 07:01 PM)digibrink Wrote:  So just by being drafted you make a little income via signing bonus?

Yep, depending upon how you define "little". These two articles provide a pretty good overview if you combine both of them:

Here's how much money players lose when they fall in the NFL Draft

Quote:Here's how much money players lose when they fall in the NFL Draft
Cork Gaines and Diana Yukari
Apr. 27, 2017, 2:42 PM

In the weeks leading up to the NFL Draft, players and agents jockey for position to be one of the top picks in the draft and cash in with a lucrative contract. This is immensely important because if a player slips in the draft, they stand to lose millions.

Last year's top pick, Jared Goff, signed a contract worth $27.9 million, while the 12th pick received less than half of that at 12.8 million. In addition, only players in the first round received contracts that were at least 70% guaranteed.

Things really drop in the second round, where the average contract was worth about $5.1 million over four years ($1.3 million per year), according to Spotrac.com, but with only half of that guaranteed. The value of third-round contracts drops to $3.3 million, but takes an even bigger hit in guaranteed value, with the average contract worth just $756,000 in guaranteed money.

Once a player falls past the third round, most draft picks will sign a 4-year deal in the $2.4-2.9 million range. The only major difference late in the draft is the signing bonus, ranging from $400,000-600,000 in the fourth round to slightly more than $60,000 in the seventh round.

[Image: sports%20cod%204-27-17.png]

NFL Draft 2017: What's the difference between an undrafted free agent and a rookie minicamp tryout?

Quote:.....Just as there are significant differences between undrafted free agents and tryout players, there are significant differences between undrafted free agents and drafted players.

Undrafted free agents sign three-year contracts for the rookie minimum, which starts at $465,000 annually. The minimum salary has built-in increases each year, so a player like Tennessee State offensive lineman Jessamen Dunker, who signed with the Giants as an undrafted free agent, will sign a three-year, $1.665 million contract.

That contract doesn't look much different than what a late-round pick will sign. The Giants picked offensive lineman Adam Bisnowaty in the sixth round (No. 200 overall). Bisnowaty will sign a four-year contract worth approximately $2.5 million. So, Bisnowaty's annual average salary will be approximately $625,000 compared to $555,000 for Dunker.

The catch is that Dunker will likely only receive a nominal a signing bonus in the $5-10,000 range. Bisnowaty, meanwhile, will be guaranteed more than $147,000 from his signing bonus...

And for those who are curious:

Quote:...During rookie minicamps, teams provide players with food, lodging and a nominal per diem. Even during training camp, players receive relatively modest compensation: $1,075 per week for every rookie and $1,900 per week for every veteran.

The key for every NFL player is to earn a spot on the 53-man roster, because they are only paid their salary during the regular season. For every week a player is on the roster, he receives 1/17th of his salary ($27,352 for a player on a minimum contract).



RE: 3 Undrafted Free Agents from One School make 53 man rosters? - Bearhawkeye - 09-05-2017 08:09 PM

(09-05-2017 08:12 AM)BearcatMan Wrote:  
(09-05-2017 07:51 AM)CliftonAve Wrote:  It is actually easier to get cut as a 6th/7th round draft pick than it is an undrafted free agent. Undrafted free agents receive a three year contract at the league minimum salary. The 6th/7th round pick will get about a $100K more a year plus a signing bonus. Therefore, many teams will cut the low draft pick over the UFA's if there is not a distinguishable difference to get the savings on the salary cap.

Exactly...

No, not really, at least if we are talking generically. I don't have the data handy, but I am very confident that a higher %age of 6th rounders and 7th rounders make the opening day rosters than do undrafted free agents.

But it's certainly possible that a specific player in a specific situation might be better off going undrafted than being a 7th round pick like if he's going to a team that is already stocked at his postion. Burfict is a guy who is probably lucky that he wasn't drafted in the 7th round by a team other than the Bengals. He had an existing relationship with Marvin and then later after he had proven his value, he was eligible to sign his 2nd contract (e.g. typically the big money one) after 3 years rather than waiting 4 years if he'd have been drafted in R7.


RE: 3 Undrafted Free Agents from One School make 53 man rosters? - JackieTreehorn - 09-07-2017 06:30 PM

Noticed that Justin Murray was signed to Tampa Bay's practice squad.


RE: 3 Undrafted Free Agents from One School make 53 man rosters? - Captain Bearcat - 09-08-2017 09:46 AM

(09-05-2017 08:09 PM)Bearhawkeye Wrote:  
(09-05-2017 08:12 AM)BearcatMan Wrote:  
(09-05-2017 07:51 AM)CliftonAve Wrote:  It is actually easier to get cut as a 6th/7th round draft pick than it is an undrafted free agent. Undrafted free agents receive a three year contract at the league minimum salary. The 6th/7th round pick will get about a $100K more a year plus a signing bonus. Therefore, many teams will cut the low draft pick over the UFA's if there is not a distinguishable difference to get the savings on the salary cap.

Exactly...

No, not really, at least if we are talking generically. I don't have the data handy, but I am very confident that a higher %age of 6th rounders and 7th rounders make the opening day rosters than do undrafted free agents.

But it's certainly possible that a specific player in a specific situation might be better off going undrafted than being a 7th round pick like if he's going to a team that is already stocked at his postion. Burfict is a guy who is probably lucky that he wasn't drafted in the 7th round by a team other than the Bengals. He had an existing relationship with Marvin and then later after he had proven his value, he was eligible to sign his 2nd contract (e.g. typically the big money one) after 3 years rather than waiting 4 years if he'd have been drafted in R7.

That's probably because the 6th/7th rounder is a better player than an undrafted free agent. That's why they were drafted.

But from the player's perspective, it's probably better to go undrafted. They can choose a team that fits them to make it less likely they'll be cut. And they're only stuck for 3 years at league minimum salary (instead of 4 years if they're drafted).