(09-10-2014 12:46 PM)goherd24herdfans Wrote:  Just spent a while tslking about BYU..... ending with talking about how the can't make the playoff even if they are undefeated..... lmao... already propaganda flying srund because they are afraid o a little guy. Several mentions of "you cant leave a pac 12 or big 12 rep out, with the acc and sec sending someone... i dont know how byu gets in...."

Their schedule is as hard as you could ask for.

@ uconn
@ texas
Houston
Virginia
Utah State
@UCF
Nevada
@Boise
@Middle Tennesee
UNLV
Savannah State
@Cal


So... that schedule undefeated absolutely should put them in the playoff. I am officially a huge BYU fan from this point on. They will do anything to keep them out. I really hope they win out and cause a huge xontroversy on the first year. Exactly why it should be 8 teams.

(09-10-2014 12:57 PM)Blueraidersig Wrote:  

(09-10-2014 12:46 PM)goherd24herdfans Wrote:  Just spent a while tslking about BYU..... ending with talking about how the can't make the playoff even if they are undefeated..... lmao... already propaganda flying srund because they are afraid o a little guy. Several mentions of "you cant leave a pac 12 or big 12 rep out, with the acc and sec sending someone... i dont know how byu gets in...."

Their schedule is as hard as you could ask for.

@ uconn
@ texas
Houston
Virginia
Utah State
@UCF
Nevada
@Boise
@Middle Tennesee
UNLV
Savannah State
@Cal


So... that schedule undefeated absolutely should put them in the playoff. I am officially a huge BYU fan from this point on. They will do anything to keep them out. I really hope they win out and cause a huge xontroversy on the first year. Exactly why it should be 8 teams.

I really hope they lose week 9.

(09-10-2014 02:05 PM)Hilltop75 Wrote:  They had a chance to get it right
But they still failed badly. You could have
Kept the bowls too.

You have 8 access bowl games.
This would have 16 teams going to the
8 bowls

The 4 winners of the 8 bowl games becomes
Your 4 team playoff.

The 16 teams could be 10 conference
Champs and 6 at large.

They had the chance to get it right but
There will always be contrversy

(09-10-2014 02:05 PM)Hilltop75 Wrote:  They had a chance to get it right
But they still failed badly. You could have
Kept the bowls too.

You have 8 access bowl games.
This would have 16 teams going to the
8 bowls

The 4 winners of the 8 bowl games becomes
Your 4 team playoff.

The 16 teams could be 10 conference
Champs and 6 at large.

They had the chance to get it right but
There will always be contrversy

(09-10-2014 02:45 PM)MUther Wrote:  

(09-10-2014 02:05 PM)Hilltop75 Wrote:  They had a chance to get it right
But they still failed badly. You could have
Kept the bowls too.

You have 8 access bowl games.
This would have 16 teams going to the
8 bowls

The 4 winners of the 8 bowl games becomes
Your 4 team playoff.

The 16 teams could be 10 conference
Champs and 6 at large.

They had the chance to get it right but
There will always be contrversy

8 bowl games have 8 winners, not 4.

(09-10-2014 04:30 PM)Attackcoog Wrote:  I see the current system quickly morphing to an 8 team playoff---the Big 10 is already miffed that it appears they are on the outside looking in. What happens when the SEC grabs two slots and there are 2 P5 champs left out. Nope, at the 6 year mark it will get modified.

(09-10-2014 04:30 PM)Attackcoog Wrote:  I see the current system quickly morphing to an 8 team playoff---the Big 10 is already miffed that it appears they are on the outside looking in. What happens when the SEC grabs two slots and there are 2 P5 champs left out. Nope, at the 6 year mark it will get modified. My guess is an 8 team playoff with each P5 champ getting an AQ slot. In order to cover themselves---the top G5 champ will get a AQ slot as well---leaving 2 wild card slots available. Everybody wins and you have a system that can last for quite some time. My guess is everything will stay as it is with the bowls--and the first round of games will be played at the home stadium of the higher ranked team allowing the extra round to simply be snapped onto the existing playoff structure. This first round will be played the weekend of the Army-Navy game (that's going to devalue that game---but oh well)---that will protect the existing season calender. They probably will even allow the first round losers to stay eligible for bowls so that the bowls still have plenty of teams to fill them. The end effect---an extra round of playoff games, more money, and the only change in the bowl structure is that they announce their invites a week later than they currently do.

(09-10-2014 04:52 PM)stinkfist Wrote:  

(09-10-2014 04:30 PM)Attackcoog Wrote:  I see the current system quickly morphing to an 8 team playoff---the Big 10 is already miffed that it appears they are on the outside looking in. What happens when the SEC grabs two slots and there are 2 P5 champs left out. Nope, at the 6 year mark it will get modified. My guess is an 8 team playoff with each P5 champ getting an AQ slot. In order to cover themselves---the top G5 champ will get a AQ slot as well---leaving 2 wild card slots available. Everybody wins and you have a system that can last for quite some time. My guess is everything will stay as it is with the bowls--and the first round of games will be played at the home stadium of the higher ranked team allowing the extra round to simply be snapped onto the existing playoff structure. This first round will be played the weekend of the Army-Navy game (that's going to devalue that game---but oh well)---that will protect the existing season calender. They probably will even allow the first round losers to stay eligible for bowls so that the bowls still have plenty of teams to fill them. The end effect---an extra round of playoff games, more money, and the only change in the bowl structure is that they announce their invites a week later than they currently do.

to save face and interest, 16 is the final number....said it from day one...

moving the ncaa out of the equation is the first step post defining p5/g5

now that that has begun....the g5 is going to suck schlong for treats like fido and a 'good boy' turd

I'm thinking it goes directly to 16.....it's a 'me' generation kinda karmak thingy from an old dude....

(09-10-2014 05:02 PM)Attackcoog Wrote:  

(09-10-2014 04:52 PM)stinkfist Wrote:  

(09-10-2014 04:30 PM)Attackcoog Wrote:  I see the current system quickly morphing to an 8 team playoff---the Big 10 is already miffed that it appears they are on the outside looking in. What happens when the SEC grabs two slots and there are 2 P5 champs left out. Nope, at the 6 year mark it will get modified. My guess is an 8 team playoff with each P5 champ getting an AQ slot. In order to cover themselves---the top G5 champ will get a AQ slot as well---leaving 2 wild card slots available. Everybody wins and you have a system that can last for quite some time. My guess is everything will stay as it is with the bowls--and the first round of games will be played at the home stadium of the higher ranked team allowing the extra round to simply be snapped onto the existing playoff structure. This first round will be played the weekend of the Army-Navy game (that's going to devalue that game---but oh well)---that will protect the existing season calender. They probably will even allow the first round losers to stay eligible for bowls so that the bowls still have plenty of teams to fill them. The end effect---an extra round of playoff games, more money, and the only change in the bowl structure is that they announce their invites a week later than they currently do.

to save face and interest, 16 is the final number....said it from day one...

moving the ncaa out of the equation is the first step post defining p5/g5

now that that has begun....the g5 is going to suck schlong for treats like fido and a 'good boy' turd

I'm thinking it goes directly to 16.....it's a 'me' generation kinda karmak thingy from an old dude....

The problem with 16 is that extends the season too long and plays into the idea that the regular season is being diluted. Don't get me wrong---I'd love 16, but I don't think the votes are ever going to be there for such an expansion. Ive said for some time--8 is the sweet spot. It covers all the bases, is reasonable, and most importantly--it is doable. In the end, they wont let perfect be the enemy of the good. Ultimately, they will pass an 8-team plan because that is what they can get support for.

(09-10-2014 05:05 PM)stinkfist Wrote:  

(09-10-2014 05:02 PM)Attackcoog Wrote:  

(09-10-2014 04:52 PM)stinkfist Wrote:  

(09-10-2014 04:30 PM)Attackcoog Wrote:  I see the current system quickly morphing to an 8 team playoff---the Big 10 is already miffed that it appears they are on the outside looking in. What happens when the SEC grabs two slots and there are 2 P5 champs left out. Nope, at the 6 year mark it will get modified. My guess is an 8 team playoff with each P5 champ getting an AQ slot. In order to cover themselves---the top G5 champ will get a AQ slot as well---leaving 2 wild card slots available. Everybody wins and you have a system that can last for quite some time. My guess is everything will stay as it is with the bowls--and the first round of games will be played at the home stadium of the higher ranked team allowing the extra round to simply be snapped onto the existing playoff structure. This first round will be played the weekend of the Army-Navy game (that's going to devalue that game---but oh well)---that will protect the existing season calender. They probably will even allow the first round losers to stay eligible for bowls so that the bowls still have plenty of teams to fill them. The end effect---an extra round of playoff games, more money, and the only change in the bowl structure is that they announce their invites a week later than they currently do.

to save face and interest, 16 is the final number....said it from day one...

moving the ncaa out of the equation is the first step post defining p5/g5

now that that has begun....the g5 is going to suck schlong for treats like fido and a 'good boy' turd

I'm thinking it goes directly to 16.....it's a 'me' generation kinda karmak thingy from an old dude....

The problem with 16 is that extends the season too long and plays into the idea that the regular season is being diluted. Don't get me wrong---I'd love 16, but I don't think the votes are ever going to be there for such an expansion. Ive said for some time--8 is the sweet spot. It covers all the bases, is reasonable, and most importantly--it is doable. In the end, they wont let perfect be the enemy of the good. Ultimately, they will pass an 8-team plan because that is what they can get support for.

the schlong ain't that long....

money...

money....

money..

dots are meaningless...you're smarter than that...................

(09-10-2014 02:05 PM)Hilltop75 Wrote:  They had a chance to get it right
But they still failed badly. You could have
Kept the bowls too.

You have 8 access bowl games.
This would have 16 teams going to the
8 bowls

The 4 winners of the 8 bowl games becomes
Your 4 team playoff.

The 16 teams could be 10 conference
Champs and 6 at large.

They had the chance to get it right but
There will always be contrversy

(09-10-2014 04:11 PM)lmckay92 Wrote:  It doesn't matter how good BYU is this year, they are independent and should not be allowed a share of the GoF bid. They should have stayed in the MWC.

(09-10-2014 05:02 PM)Attackcoog Wrote:  

(09-10-2014 04:52 PM)stinkfist Wrote:  

(09-10-2014 04:30 PM)Attackcoog Wrote:  I see the current system quickly morphing to an 8 team playoff---the Big 10 is already miffed that it appears they are on the outside looking in. What happens when the SEC grabs two slots and there are 2 P5 champs left out. Nope, at the 6 year mark it will get modified. My guess is an 8 team playoff with each P5 champ getting an AQ slot. In order to cover themselves---the top G5 champ will get a AQ slot as well---leaving 2 wild card slots available. Everybody wins and you have a system that can last for quite some time. My guess is everything will stay as it is with the bowls--and the first round of games will be played at the home stadium of the higher ranked team allowing the extra round to simply be snapped onto the existing playoff structure. This first round will be played the weekend of the Army-Navy game (that's going to devalue that game---but oh well)---that will protect the existing season calender. They probably will even allow the first round losers to stay eligible for bowls so that the bowls still have plenty of teams to fill them. The end effect---an extra round of playoff games, more money, and the only change in the bowl structure is that they announce their invites a week later than they currently do.

to save face and interest, 16 is the final number....said it from day one...

moving the ncaa out of the equation is the first step post defining p5/g5

now that that has begun....the g5 is going to suck schlong for treats like fido and a 'good boy' turd

I'm thinking it goes directly to 16.....it's a 'me' generation kinda karmak thingy from an old dude....

The problem with 16 is that extends the season too long and plays into the idea that the regular season is being diluted. Don't get me wrong---I'd love 16, but I don't think the votes are ever going to be there for such an expansion. Ive said for some time--8 is the sweet spot. It covers all the bases, is reasonable, and most importantly--it is doable. In the end, they wont let perfect be the enemy of the good. Ultimately, they will pass an 8-team plan because that is what they can get support for.